7 Comments
User's avatar
Brantly Womack's avatar

Excellent essay. I make a similar point in a recent book, arguing that China's position as the "solid center" of East Asia, based on central presence, more than half of the region's population, and production of trade goods such as tea, silk, and "china," can be contrasted to the "liquid centers" of the West, the Mediterranean and later the Atlantic around and through which circulated competitive and expansionist empires. China wanted a quiet perimeter; the West pursued profitable frontiers.

Expand full comment
QQ's avatar

Thank you for sharing. May I ask if you were aware Dr Shan has joined Substack? https://open.substack.com/pub/weijianshan/p/shatter-the-mirror

Expand full comment
Jiang Jiang's avatar

Yes, and his account on Substack is in the byline of this post

Expand full comment
QQ's avatar

My apologies, I missed that. I clicked the "Shan Weijian" link thinking it would go to his Substack, but instead it unexpectedly goes to the SCMP profile.

Expand full comment
Jiang Jiang's avatar

No worries. Just click his name on the byline and it will work. Thanks for the note!

Expand full comment
Erl Happ's avatar

I loved Out of the Gobi. This article makes a lot of sense.

Expand full comment
Richard Wheeler's avatar

Thank you. Clarity overcomes bullshit, hopefully every time.

Expand full comment